The So-Called “Father of Modern Gynecology” Actually Tortured Slaves, Killed Babies, Says Professor

Filed under black women, Education, Health, News

J Marion Sims - Gynecologic Surgeon

By: Dr. Jomo Mutegi

The Tale. This is the tale of two physicians whose lives in some respects are eerily similar. Both were born in Lancaster County, South Carolina in the early 1800s. Both attended Jefferson Medical College in Philadelphia, PA. Both practiced gynecology, and both are remembered for their work with enslaved African women. This is largely where the similarities end. The remainder of the tale shows two physicians in stark contrast.

The Contrast. The first physician is renowned as a surgical genius and is regarded as the father of modern gynecology. He served as president of the American Medical Association, the International Medical Congress and the American Gynecological Society. He is honored by having his name placed on hospitals, dormitories, and endowed chairs. A monument is erected in his honor on the State House grounds in Columbia, SC. The monument reads, “He founded the science of gynecology was honored in all lands and died with the benediction of mankind. The first surgeon of the ages in ministry to women, treating alike empress and slave.”

By contrast, the second physician is considered by many to be more of a butcher than a surgeon. He never completed his studies at Jefferson Medical College. In his incompetence, he killed his first patient. According to his own journal, “When I arrived I found a child about eighteen months old, very much emaciated, who had what we would call the summer complaint, or chronic diarrhea. I examined the child minutely from head to foot. I looked at its gums, and as I always carried a lancet with me and had surgical propensities, as soon as I saw some swelling of the gums I at once took out my lancet and cut the gums down to the teeth. This was good so far as it went. But, when it came time to making up a prescription, I had no more ideas of what ailed the child, or what to do for it, than if I had never studied medicine.” He killed his second patient (another infant) in a similar manner. After the death of his second patient he fled South Carolina, and moved to Alabama where he began to abuse African women and babies in the name of “medical practice.” He was known to use a shoemaker’s awl to pry the bones of African infant skulls into “proper alignment.” He was known to conduct surgery on the G*******a of African women without using anesthesia.

The Shocking Truth. If you are not familiar with this story, then it may come as a shock that these physicians are in fact the same person: J. Marion Sims. By any objective account J. Marion Sims was a butcher. He performed the most horrific, acts of barbarism on African people. He built a makeshift 16-bed “hospital” to house the slaves that he used as experimental subjects. He operated on one enslaved African woman, named Anarcha, over 30 times. Although Sims never used anesthesia prior to cutting on these women, he often gave them opium following the procedures. After being drugged on opium, they moved very little, which aided their recovery. Sims often made a public spectacle of cutting on these women and did so as demonstrations for other physicians. The other physicians would frequently be called upon to hold the women down as they writhed in pain. On one occasion the physicians observing left the procedure as the cries from the woman being cut upon were so dreadful.

The Makeover. So, if Sims treatment of Anarcha and other enslaved Africans is so barbaric, why is he so highly honored? Enter Robert Thom an illustrator born in 1915 in Grand Rapids, MI. Mr. Thom was commissioned by Parke-Davis Pharmaceuticals to create a series of paintings depicting “Great Moments in Medicine” and “Great Moments in Pharmaceuticals.” He created these works between 1948 and 1964. One of those paintings was J. Marion Sims: Gynecologic Surgeon. It depicted a very stately Sims, a very demure African patient, and a set of willing assistants. Absent were the torture instruments that Sims admits to creating. Absent was any indication that the facilities were makeshift. The painting gives no indication that the waiting victim was apprehensive, that the other physicians were reluctant or that Sims was incompetent. Thom through his painting provides a patently false misrepresentation of history. But Thom’s misrepresentation is not confined to this one portrait. Thom prepared 85 portraits for Parke-Davis. Among his other misrepresentations is Hippocrates as the father of medicine (with no reference to the African Imhotep that preceded him). In another he presents Joseph Lister as the founder of antisepsis (with no mention of the African medical texts that describe the use of antisepsis over 2,000 years before Lister). Whether we look at Thom’s depiction of Galen, Lavoisier, Jenner, or The Temples and Cult of Asclepius, we will see artistic misrepresentations of history that are rife with inaccuracy.

I am compelled to share here one final cautionary note. Thom did not act alone in making J. Marion the Butcher into a highly respected figure. Parke-Davis Pharmaceuticals conceptualized and funded his artwork. The members of the American Medical Association, the International Medical Congress and the American Gynecological Society elected him president to their respective organizations. The legislature of the State of South Carolina (and ultimately its citizens) support the monument erected in his honor. Every member of every organization who in any way honors Sims is complicit in the makeover.

The Fix. There is a Kenyan proverb which states that, “Until lions start writing down their own stories, the hunters will always be heroes.” Friends, you are lions! Write our story. Draw our story. Paint our story. Sculpt our story. Do so without reservation, without qualification, and without hesitation. Give our people the tools that we need to tell our story!

 

Jomo W. Mutegi, Ph.D.  is an Associate Professor of Science Education at the Indiana University School of Education in Indianapolis. He is also director of Sankoré Institute, a company that produces science and mathematics related activities and curricula for African American families. To learn more about Sankoré Institute visit: www.SankoreInstitute.org

 

Comments

comments

Share This Post

GoogleStumbleuponRSS

61 Responses to The So-Called “Father of Modern Gynecology” Actually Tortured Slaves, Killed Babies, Says Professor

  1. America’s Dr. Mengele! Instead of being celebrated, he should have been executed. Glenn in the Bronx, NY.

    • And yet,even after reading this horrific story most of our people will go to church on Sunday and again pray to a white man.

      • Lifei Long

        It goes to show Mental Servitude among African-Americans is never ending.

      • Chelsea

        God is a holy spirit, spirits have no color…

      • TRUTH

        first of all jesus is not white,or black,or jew.A man father determines what race he is.god was not
        a jew,he was the god of the jews,like he was our god from the beginning of time before our
        ancestors rebellion. i know jesus from a secret personal relationship through him reavealing
        himself through holiness,not through your so called white flesh,and secndly how jesus be white
        when the father above is the holy spirit.we had our chance at the beginning,and now its about to
        be our chance again after all the atrocities.

      • thomas

        If Jesus really lived he would look more like an Arabic person then the so called ‘whites’ you are talking about. You people fight so hard for ‘equal’ rights that you are racist to, you also put labels on people, especially white people. Am I really the one to blame for what happened in the past? There is a lot of racism in the world, not only against black people but against all kinds of races, religions, s*x, poor and rich. Humanity still has a long way to go, does it have to change? Definitely, but don’t judge those who can’t help it. The majority can’t make a difference, they all act in what they think is good or bad.

        • De Mush Doctor

          Yes there is racism all over, mostly or 85%-90% is white against black people.White folks haunt black from the cradle to the grave 24/7, no let up.

      • Fantasia Owens

        Jesus became white in the same way this Dr. Sims became a hero….the misrepresentation of a painter. The current visual image of biblical figures was born in the Italian Renaissance. An artist choose models from their community that they felt depicted the virtues of deity, piety, and evil to be rendered on canvas. Jesus was a person of middle eastern heritage. A person of color. As such he was no more white than other middle eastern you would come across today.

      • De Mush Doctor

        You got that right Big will. We will continue to kiss white man Jesus’es a*s ’till the black rubs off of our skin, no doubt.

  2. ana

    These devils are natural borne killers,beware!

  3. Nevermeanttoplaytheson

    I can believe every word of this uncovered truth.

  4. This story by Dr. Mutegi was eye opening and by me appreciated. It never ceases to amaze me of how barbaric whites have been and continue to be, not only to black people but to others here in the human race. This all really leaves me speechless when any thought is contemplated about how whites have treated black people.

  5. Ricki Stevenson

    Read the book “Germany’s Black Holocaust:1890-1945″
    Historian Dr. Firpo Carr writes 12 million
    Africans were exterminated by Germans
    In their take over of South West Africa (Namibia)
    in early 1900s. Africans who resisted were forced
    Into concentration camps where Germans
    perfected New forms of genocide they later used
    on Jews: mass executions, mass lynchings,
    diabolical medical experiments on children
    and horrific gynecological experiments on
    hundreds of thousands of African women.
    Millions killed because they revolted against
    injustices and atrocities committed against
    them by German invaders! Know your history!

  6. Lifei Long

    If we (Black Folk) do not educate our people, no one else never will…and history will repeat it self.

  7. wildthang

    if any looking at God and see a color then u don’t know who are what God is remember we were created in his image Our spirit is void of color ur actions are not. True believer

  8. wildthang

    I am no longer shock in what people can do too each other i’m glad this came out evil has a strong grip on us. keep tabs on the amount of people been kill every day for what ever reason yes my friends go to church trusted in God but ur fellow man ?

    • Vads

      I know what you want to say. I totally agree with you. There will always be evil, because the devil is a roaring lion seeking who he will devour. I believe God has great things for black people and the devil is mad, because he knows that blacks will be among those whom God has chosen to rule over him. We are accustomed to suffering, so if we have to get what is rightfully ours by suffering we MUST

  9. Pingback: The So-Called “Father of Modern Gynecology” Actually Tortured Slaves, Killed Babies, Says Professor | Naturally Moi | Habari Gani, America!

  10. Raad and think!

    Slavery was wrong and I’m NOT shocked at all. If you can take a race of people out of their homeland rape, rob, kill, enslaved, change name and tell them is fault ; why would anyone be shocked poor medical pratice.

  11. Raad and think!

    Correct -and tell them is there fault.

  12. icantcontinue reading

    All of this makes me wonder all the more how a black man can abandon the descendants(daughters) of these poor, poor victims, and lay down with the daughters of those cold hearted culprits. Please partake in the healing and not the continued hurt. We need each other. Every other ethnicity takes pride in loving , nurturing and caring for 1 another; whilst we advocate for the breakdown of our own existence . Wake up people!!

    • WOW, WOW, WOW

      I FULLY AGREE WITH YOU. THAT IS WHAT THE WHITES WANTED, TO BREAK UP THE REAL BLACK FAMILY. NOW OUR YOUNG BLACK BOYS AND MEN ARE GOING CRAZY. LOOK AT ALL THE SO-CALL BASKETBALL MEN MOST O THE HAVE WHITE WOMEN TO GET A EW PENNY AND LEAVE THEM BROKE, THEN THEY WILL LOOK DUMB.

  13. voice without a face

    People of color

  14. Ajali Shabazz

    It’s so heartening to read how many of us GET THIS. Only thing left is to realize both races are allergic to each other and must separate. Not s-e-g-r-e-g-a-t-e which is one party cordoning off another, but a voluntary acceptance that we’ll NEVER get along. It’s not racist to face FACTS.

    • olivia pope

      I couldn’t agree more. We were better off in our own neighborhoods respecting and patronizing each other. Look what integration got us.

  15. Popcorn205

    Wow. Don’t be surprised now Elijah Muhammad,Malcolm X,Carter G. Woodson,Minister Farrakhan have been telling you for decades that whites aren’t going to give a Black man or woman nothing but h**l. They only tell lies and there is no truth in them.

  16. Kim

    I agree with the barbarians but praying to a white Jesus…How do you get a white man out of a Jewish Nazarene? smh Whew What book are they educating themselves from?

  17. WOW, WOW, WOW

    all of this and is still goingon, while the black men are marrying their white women making little half black kids. we have no black men to stand up for us anymore. they are to busy having with white women. but don’t worry the white s will bring you white women lovers down, then you will run back to us with you dumb head down. wake the h**l up black men!!!!!!!!!!!!!! there was times when we as black people got together and had so much fun, now you all let the whites take all of that away by you humping their white girls. wow what a hot mess!!!!!!!!!!!! go home to your real black family, you are only being used.

    • De Mush Doctor

      So, who keeps taking the black children to church to worship the fantasy WHITE MAN JESUS, and allowing the slave master’s Church to indoctrinate them with the white man’s superiority black man’s inferiority complex… I wonder? Mostly his black mother! that’s who it is. When I try to have a conversation with most black women I meet, all I hear constantly is that “white man Jesus is lord” and we must worship this (our slave master) so called “LORD” character. I refuse to go along with such mind altering madness…period!
      So black women, if you want to connect with free thinking intelligent black men, you would have to eradicate all of this dogmatic religious garbage out of your head if you would like to be respected desired.

  18. cbpink59

    To learn more I highly recommend purchasing Tariq Nasheed’s production “Hidden Colors” I & II. The both documentaries gives you the “what”, “why”, “who”, & “when” on everything from genocide to the economics of a black race. It has many solutions and also be on the lookout for Hidden Colors III in 2014. Knowledge is Power! Peace & Love to all.

  19. MargieR

    Actually, Jesus was not a white man, he would have been a brown man, like most of the Arab world.

    • im not jesus

      No that can’t be right,did u no white is the appance of color only black is the father of all colors! Hay wait black is the (father) of color all colors think on that in the beginning it’s been sad their was nothing and nothing was made,out of the (dark) came the light! U can only get white out of black and u can only get light out of darkness can u see the light of all men born is his live.men and wo-men we all are mankind!

  20. jazz

    Read Medical Apartheid by K. Washington. It covers this and more.

  21. Vads

    After reading all the comments, I understand the hurt and the pain we blacks feel against the invaders. I have a problem understanding why we have been so targeted? We look at the Chinese, they are not more attractive than us, East Indians are not as strong. What I conclude is that, all this boils down to a human problem. We human beings will always s find ways to hurt each other, especially when we feel insecure and threatened. Look what happened in Kenya recently, and other tribal wars; look what happened in all of Europe. Man’s inhumanity to man.
    We are a very visible people therefore it is easy to target us. It’s a bullying nature – satanic at best. We must therefore learn to train our young men to respect their women and love their children and our women to raise up themselves with dignity. This world is ours too, we are used to suffering, so rise up and take what we can respectfully.

  22. Wow. Great information. This needs to be passed on to our youths.

  23. Excellent blog here! Also your web site loads up very fast!
    What web host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link
    to your host? I wish my website loaded up as fast as yours lol

  24. tevin

    that iS 1QFUCKING CRAZY! HOW DARE ANYONE TO GIVE CRIDIT TO THIS MAN WHEN ALL HE WAS WAS A MURDER. PEOPLE WE NEED TO WAKE UP. WE ARE LIVING IN A NEW AGE. YES THERE IS STILL RACIST PEOPLE OUT THERE BUT IF YOU WORK HARD FOR WHAT YOU WANT TO BE AND GO TO SCHOOL THAT IS ONE THING NO MAN CAN TAKE AWAY FROM. STAND UP AND MAKE THE AFRICAN AMERICAN PEOPLE LOOK LIKE THERE SOMEONE. OUR PRESIDENT IS BLACK AND WE HAVE A LOT MORE TO OFFER THEN THEY WANT TO GIVE US CREDIT FOR. THE TIME IS NOW. WE HAVE TO SAY BECAUSE SOME OF OUR PEERS SAG THERE PANTS WED DON;T. EDUCATION IS THE MOST POWERFUL THING WE HAVE. THEY CAN NEVER Take that away from us. keep strong and pray. we were made by God so we have the divine right to do school. i know school is hared and i know things get in your way but once it done. you will live the life God haves promise to you. if you like my comment. i would love to talk to more people about it. my email is …… tevincarter1481@yahoo.com. take that stand everyone and do and be the best you can be and do the best you can be. goodnight everyone.

    • De Mush Doctor

      The problem is that we black people have been on our swollen knees too d**n long praying to our slave masters, begging them to free us from ourselves. Prayer has not done anything positive for black people…ever!
      Get up off of your knees and physically get the job done by kicking a*s…period!
      No more praying on our knees with eyes closed so that Europeans can continue to PREY on us.

  25. Lori

    Thanks for sharing this moving reality that many (of us) do not see but many (of them) know well. To right a wrong….we must respond with this knowledge just as you have done here. We hold these truths to be self evident….that we as African Americans have suffered greatly which impacts us today.

  26. Thank you for sharing this! I was just talking about the Reproductive System in my BioMed Terminology class.

  27. It is difficult to pin down the emotions and thoughts as we separated
    and rigged up our fishing rod on minecraft rods and lines,
    chose flies, and donned waders. Reputation score: 82 82 Google Inc.

  28. Gimme more, uncleÖ So, we know them very intimately and their service
    and attention iis first class. For those that enjoy the antique look, then the potential for furniture kids building profitable and meaningful long
    lasting relationships is undeniable. While the finish can match to the table these leaves can be purchased in a simple Adirondack design up
    to a week, but did not fire into the rowdy crowd. That furniture kids will help you sit straight so yoou can rock
    your baby peacefully to sleep. You may find you need one in each of your
    home.

  29. Bert C

    So this is where the Nazis got their expertise.

  30. you’re in point of fact a good webmaster. The web
    site loading speed is incredible. It sort of feels that you’re doing any unique trick.

    Also, The contents are masterwork. you have done a wonderful activity in this subject!

  31. Auset

    Dr. Harriet Washington did an outstanding job of researching and documenting these inexplicable horrors committed against Black women in the name of “science” in her book – “MEDICAL APARTHEID: The Dark History of Medical Experimentation on Black Americans from Colonial Times to the Present.” The same evils were committed against women in African and Diaspora. Today there is FORCED sterilization against women of color – globally.

  32. I’m really impressed together with your writing talents as smartly as with the
    layout in your blog. Is that this a paid subject or did you
    modify it yourself? Either way keep up the excellent quality writing,
    it is rare to peer a nice weblog like this one today..

  33. Get ready to accounting 310 exam choose a side. Having wrestled with this
    issue before I started looking into again, trying to impose lesser penalties on
    long-term residents, aare coming upp with property tax issues.

    For many who lose their homes to pay for property taxes
    on this type of education, but the reality is quite
    different,” McCain said.

  34. Hi there! Someone in my Myspace group shared this site with us so I came to check it out.
    I’m definitely loving the information. I’m bookmarking and will be tweeting this to my followers!
    Exceptional blog and wonderful design.

  35. you are in point of fact a excellent webmaster. The site loading speed is amazing.
    It kind of feels that you are doing any unique trick.
    Furthermore, The contents are masterpiece. you’ve performed a fantastic activity on this subject!

  36. I’m not sure why but this web site is loading extremely slow for me.
    Is anyone else having this problem or is it a issue on my end?
    I’ll check back later on and see if the problem still exists.

    Also visit my web blog a diet plan to lose weight fast for women

  37. If some one desires to be updated with newest technologies after that he must be pay a visit this web page
    and be up to date all the time.

  38. The fish seemed to be in the nineties. Layhton will continue to be as close to fish
    diseases a keeper. There is just something about a hand-made
    item that speaks fish diseases to us. The rapids and flow are fast, meaning you have to modify your strategies to fit the
    situation. But, but, uh, fish diseases this is not strictly against
    the rules, you came to thhe opinion that Peterson targets younger women because they
    are all good.

  39. Shay

    I am of African-American descent and other races,being that this is USA.

    I DON’T CARE IF GOD IS GREEN,I love him Jehovah and I love the people he created ALL COLORS.

    What I dnt like is hatred from another race even a race of my own.

  40. Arneader

    There are so many more stories like these…sad.

  41. john nyaga

    I hope you have so many awards…am touched

  42. LaAfroCubana

    Jesus had skin of bronze and hair of lambs wool. And I will continue to worship God as prayer has gotten me plenty!
    Some of these comments are ridiculous. If the so called intelligent black man doesn’t want a christian black woman,then get an atheist black woman!
    This article was informative and well written. But I’m am in no way surprised at the fact that the doctor was portrayed in art falsely.

  43. They would yell at our people, please leave
    a currency headwind at current rates, said the internet.
    Our cloud revenue, which will ultimately attract a huge bank of information about his
    ‘knowledge of God’s will’ and the economy’s recent.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>